Troubleshooting a Runny Toilet: 5 Possible Reasons and Solutions

December 7, 2023

Understanding Your Toilet System

Ah, the curious case of a perpetually running toilet! You’ve found the right place to find clarity on this watery woe. Addressing a runny toilet issue is vital not only for your water bill but also for the environment. So, let’s delve into the five most common causes of a runny toilet and their respective solutions.

A toilet system seems simple but comprises several intricate components working in harmony. The key features include the fill valve, flapper, overflow tube, fill tube, and float. Each part plays a vital role, and when one malfunctions, the entire toilet system may go awry.

Toilet Issues and Solutions

Not Enough Water in Cistern

The toilet cistern not filling up is a common culprit when troubleshooting a running toilet, and understanding this issue is crucial for an effective resolution. If you notice that the toilet tank is consistently low on water, it can lead to incomplete flushes and prolonged refilling times.

One primary reason for this problem is a faulty fill valve that fails to allow adequate water to enter the cistern after each colour. To address this, inspect the fill valve for any signs of wear or malfunction and consider adjusting its settings if necessary. Sometimes, a simple adjustment to the float arm or the valve can ensure a proper water level, facilitating a more efficient flushing process.


When faced with insufficient water in the cistern, seeking professional solutions ensures a comprehensive and lasting resolution. Professional plumbers bring a wealth of expertise to the table, allowing them to diagnose the specific cause of the problem quickly. In the case of a malfunctioning fill valve, professionals can efficiently repair or replace the faulty component, restoring the proper water level in the cistern. Additionally, they have the skills to assess and address any issues with the water supply valve, ensuring it is fully open and free from blockages that may impede water flow.

Faulty Fill Valve

The fill valve serves as the traffic controller for the water supply to your toilet, managing the water inflow flow into the tank following every flush. The water may continuously run if the valve prevents water and is worn out or damaged. To assess your fill valve, follow these steps:


Professionals systematically address a faulty fill valve to restore a toilet’s proper functionality. When confronted with a malfunctioning fill valve, the first step is a thorough inspection to identify the specific issue. It may involve checking for visible damage, mineral deposits, or debris that could impede the valve’s performance. Once the problem is pinpointed, the professional may opt for repairs, such as cleaning or replacing damaged components. If repairs are impractical, we might recommend a complete replacement of the fill valve. Professionals are equipped with the expertise to select the appropriate replacement parts or entire fill valve assembly, ensuring compatibility with the toilet model. Their adeptness in swiftly disassembling and reassembling toilet components minimises downtime and provides a reliable resolution to the faulty fill valve, allowing the toilet to function optimally once again.

The Problem with the Flapper

Picture the flapper as a gatekeeper. It seals shut the tank’s opening, retaining water until the tank is next flush. A warped or damaged flapper allows water from the tank to leak, leading to a constant filling cycle. To troubleshoot a malfunctioning flapper:


A common issue associated with a running toilet often stems from problems with the flapper. The flapper is a crucial component that seals and turns off the water flush valve at the bottom of the tank. When this rubber or plastic valve becomes worn, misaligned, or damaged, it fails to close properly, allowing water to leak from the tank into the bowl continuously. This persistent leakage triggers the fill valve to refill the tank, resulting in a running toilet repeatedly. The signs of a faulty flapper include a toilet that constantly makes a hissing or running water sound even when not in use. Fortunately, resolving this problem is relatively straightforward. Homeowners can quickly determine whether a replacement is necessary by inspecting the flapper for visible signs of wear, misalignment, or damage. Flapper replacement kits are widely available and provide a cost-effective solution to restore proper toilet functioning and eliminate water wastage.

Leaky Fill Tube

The fill tube aims to refill the flushed-out bowl after each flush. Although less common, a leaky fill tube may cause a running to flush the toilet. To troubleshoot and fix a leaky fill tube:


A leaky fill tube in a toilet can be a common culprit behind a running toilet. The fill tube directs water into the overflow pipe and refills the water line in the bowl after a flush. Moisture can continuously escape When the fill tube leaks, is damaged or is improperly connected, leading to a persistent running sound. This issue often arises when the fill tube is disconnected or cracks, allowing water to spill onto the floor instead of into the overflow pipe.

To resolve this problem, inspect the fill tube for any visible damage, secure any loose connections, and, if necessary, may need to replace the fill tube with a new one. Ensuring a properly functioning fill tube is crucial for maintaining the correct water level in the remaining water in the tank and preventing unnecessary water waste.

Incorrect Float Height

Maintaining the correct float height is crucial to prevent your toilet from running. The fill valve and ball float will keep replenishing the water supply line in the tank if the float doesn’t reach a certain level. To adjust the float height:


Incorrect float height in a toilet tank can lead to various issues, primarily affecting the toilet’s flushing mechanism. When the float height is set too high, it causes the water level in the tank rise above the overflow pipe. This excess water triggers a continuous flush, leading to a constantly running toilet. Conversely, if the float height in the toilet tank is set too low, the toilet may not flush adequately, resulting in insufficient water entering the bowl. Adjusting the float height is crucial for achieving the right balance, ensuring the proper functioning of the fill valve and preventing unnecessary water waste.

Homeowners can rectify this problem by adjusting the float lift arm or modifying or replacing the rod connecting the float to the fill valve. Regularly checking and maintaining the correct float height contributes to an efficiently operating toilet system and helps conserve water.

Prevention of Future Toilet Troubles

To maintain a trouble-free toilet system, incorporating regular maintenance practices is essential. It includes diligent cleaning of flappers and thorough inspections of connections. By adhering to a routine that involves proactive monitoring and care, you can identify potential issues before they escalate, ensuring your toilet’s long-term reliability and functionality.

Regular Inspections:

Conducting routine toilet inspections by a professional is crucial to preventing future plumbing problems. Periodically check for any signs of leaks, cracks, or malfunctioning components. Timely addressing these minor issues can prevent them from evolving into major and costly problems, saving you time and resources. A proactive approach to toilet maintenance extends the lifespan of your plumbing fixtures and ensures the overall efficiency of your bathroom facilities.

Mindful Flushing:

Promoting responsible flushing habits within your household is a key preventive measure. Remind family members to flush only toilet-friendly items, discouraging disposing of non-disposable items such as sanitary napkins, wipes, and excessive amounts of toilet paper. This simple practice goes a long way in preventing clogs and maintaining the optimal functioning of your toilet system.

Adjust Float and Water Level:

Regularly checking and adjusting the tank’s float height and water level is a proactive step in preventing toilet malfunctions. Ensuring these elements are set at optimal levels prevents potential issues such as running toilets, which can lead to water wastage and the risk of overflow. Incorporating this preventive measure contributes to your toilet’s overall efficiency and longevity.

Use Toilet Safe Cleaning Products:

Selecting cleaning products specifically designed for toilets is crucial to prevent damage to internal components. Harsh chemicals can potentially deteriorate essential parts such as the flapper, fill valve and other mechanisms. By choosing toilet-safe cleaning products, you not only maintain the cleanliness of your toilet but also safeguard its longevity and prevent unnecessary wear and tear. This conscientious choice in cleaning practices contributes to your toilet system’s overall health and durability.

Troubleshoot the Problems Immediately

In conclusion, understanding the root causes of a persistently running toilet is not just a matter of convenience; it’s a proactive step towards significant savings in money and resources. By promptly identifying and addressing issues contributing to toilet leaks, homeowners can prevent the unnecessary waste of gallons of water, conserving this precious resource and substantially reducing water bills. Moreover, a swift fix to a running toilet goes beyond the immediate financial impact, as it safeguards the overall health of your plumbing system, mitigating the risk of more severe and costly damages in the long run. Whether it’s a faulty flapper, a malfunctioning fill valve, or issues with the flush handle, promptly troubleshooting and resolving these concerns can add considerable savings over time.

 As we navigate the intricacies of household maintenance, it becomes evident that small, proactive measures can have lasting positive effects.  Ask a professional cistern plumber for help fixing a runny toilet and any related issues. Together, we can contribute to a more sustainable and resource-conscious approach to home maintenance.

Soho is your expert team in Australian real estate, offering an innovative platform for effortless property searches. With deep insights into buying, renting, and market trends, we guide you to make informed decisions, whether it's your first home or exploring new suburbs.
Share this article
Don’t waste time searching for a home. Let our AI do the work


Soho logo

Our AI match engine will match you with over 150,000+ properties and you can swipe away or shortlist easily. Making your home buying journey faster and easier 

Soho logo
Our AI match engine will match you with over 150,000+ properties and you can swipe away or shortlist easily. Making your home buying journey faster and easier.