What Are the Riskiest Suburbs to Buy Property in Melbourne?

November 25, 2023
What are the riskiest suburbs to buy property Melbourne?

Key takeaways:

  • Melbourne’s property market is rebounding with a 4.5% price increase since January 2023.
  • Windsor, St Kilda, and other suburbs are the riskiest for property investment due to significant price declines.
  • The city’s infrastructure is under strain from rapid population growth.
  • Stabilization is evident in the housing market, but house and unit markets are diverging.

In 2023, Melbourne’s property market reveals a mix of stabilizing trends and risk areas, particularly in certain suburbs. Addressing the question, “What are the riskiest suburbs to buy property in Melbourne?” this article discusses the most challenging suburbs in Melbourne to consider for property investment.

We will explore the suburbs with the steepest price falls, the wider implications of these trends on the property market, and the potential risks for buyers and investors.

Specific focus will be given to the suburbs that have experienced significant declines in property values, as well as the overall health of Melbourne’s property market, considering recent economic challenges and the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Recent Price Trends in Melbourne’s Property Market

What are the riskiest suburbs to buy property Melbourne?

Melbourne’s real estate landscape in 2023 shows a complex picture. After a significant rise in property prices by 15.8% during 2020 and 2021, the market saw a downturn, with housing values falling by 7.9% from their peak in March 2022 to January 2023.

However, there’s a twist in the tale. Since January 2023, there’s been a consistent rise in prices, now up by 4.5%. This indicates a potential turnaround, suggesting a window of opportunity for buyers and investors as the Melbourne market picks up momentum again.

“This recovery, though, comes with its own set of challenges. The city has weathered the economic fallout of the COVID-19 pandemic, extended lockdowns, a series of interest rate hikes, and the lowest level of consumer confidence in decades.”

These factors have collectively influenced the property market dynamics, leading to a cautious but hopeful outlook for the future. With this backdrop, Melbourne’s property market is at a crucial juncture, where understanding the recent price trends becomes essential for anyone looking to invest in the city’s real estate.

Suburbs with the Steepest Declines

Identifying the riskiest suburbs in Melbourne is crucial for informed property investment decisions in 2023. Certain Melbourne suburbs have witnessed the largest falls in house and unit prices over the past year.

For instance, Windsor experienced a significant -14.1% fall in median house prices, while St Kilda saw a -12.4% decline. South Melbourne, Malvern East, and Middle Park also faced notable drops in house prices, ranging from -10.9% to -12.2%.

Table 1: Decline in Median House Prices

SuburbDecline in Median House Prices (%)
St Kilda-12.4%
South Melbourne-12.2%
Malvern East-11.3%
Middle Park-10.9%
Source: API magazine

In the unit market, the scenario is equally concerning. Suburbs like Kew East and Hawthorn East have seen steep falls in unit prices, plummeting by -18.5% and -18.1%, respectively. Other suburbs like Ascot Vale, Hawthorn, and Moonee Ponds also reported significant drops in unit prices, with declines exceeding -16%.

These substantial price falls point to a market adjustment, underscoring the importance of cautious investment in these areas. Understanding these dynamics is key for potential buyers and investors, especially those considering properties in these specific Melbourne suburbs.

Table 2: Decline in Median Unit Prices

SuburbDecline in Median Unit Prices (%)
Kew East-18.5%
Hawthorn East-18.1%
Ascot Vale-17.1%
Moonee Ponds-16.3%
Source: API magazine

Population Growth and Infrastructure Strain

Melbourne’s population surge poses significant challenges for the city’s infrastructure. The population is forecasted to increase by around 500,000 over the next five years, and by a staggering 1.7 million since the start of the century.

This rapid growth, equivalent to adding two cities the size of Hobart in just five years, strains Melbourne’s public transport and roads, leading to overcrowding and congestion.

“The rental market feels this impact too, with a historic low in vacancy rates and a 23.1% soar in apartment rents over the past year, making it tough for tenants to find affordable living spaces.”

For those interested in exploring more affordable options, understanding where the cheapest rentals in Victoria are can be beneficial.

As Melbourne overtakes Sydney to become Australia’s largest city by population, the strain on infrastructure intensifies. Public transport struggles to keep up with demand, leading to delays and overcrowding. Roads are increasingly congested, complicating daily commutes.

To mitigate these challenges, the Victorian government commits to substantial investment in public transport infrastructure. This rapid growth and the resultant strain on city infrastructure are crucial considerations for anyone looking to invest in Melbourne’s property market.

Market Recovery and Future Outlook

What are the riskiest suburbs to buy property Melbourne?

The Melbourne property market is showing signs of stabilisation, with a slight drop of 0.5%, or $5,017, in house prices during the March quarter, indicating a possible market floor.

Despite this, experts caution that a definitive confirmation of this trend requires more time. Melbourne’s median house price, currently at $1,023,116, is still 6.5% below its December 2021 peak but 16.1% higher than pre-pandemic levels. This suggests a resilient market that has withstood recent economic upheavals.

According to a report by Urban Developer, Melbourne is set to become the nation’s fastest-growing city and is projected to overtake Sydney as the biggest capital in Australia by 2030.

The Centre for Population’s latest projections indicated a gradual increase in population growth, particularly from 2023‑2024 onwards, with Melbourne expected to become the nation’s largest city in 2029‑2030 with just over 5.9 million people.

“Mornington Peninsula and Inner East, are recovering, a typical pattern in real estate cycles. This rebound in expensive areas, coupled with returning buyer confidence and a pause in interest rate rises, points towards a market bottoming out. “

For insights into the most affluent areas, one might consider exploring where most millionaires live in Melbourne.

However, while house prices show signs of stabilising, unit prices tell a different story. They’ve fallen 4.8% to a $527,828 median, with the steepest drops in places like the Mornington Peninsula according to The Age. This dichotomy in the housing market underscores the need for careful consideration and market analysis before making property investments in Melbourne.

For those looking into rental investments, examining the Melbourne rental properties market is essential.

Learn More: Interested in more options? Our detailed guide to the best suburbs to live in Melbourne is just one click away and complements the insights you’ve gained here.

FAQs on What Are the Riskiest Suburbs to Buy Property in Melbourne?

What are the most undervalued suburbs in Melbourne?

According to discussing Melbourne’s property market, some of the most undervalued suburbs include:

  • Albion: Known for its potential and proximity, only 17 kilometers from Melbourne’s CBD, offering a balance of accessibility and tranquility.
  • Reservoir: A suburb offering value for property investors or homebuyers.
  • Fawkner: Another suburb with untapped potential, attractive for its affordability.
  • Frankston: Recognized for its affordability, despite being a coastal area.

What are the up and coming suburbs in Melbourne?

In terms of growth and potential, the top suburbs in Melbourne, as noted by a property market source, are:

  • Wandin East
  • Wandin North
  • Seville
  • Gruyere
  • Seville East
  • Narre Warren South

These suburbs are identified for their significant development and growth prospects.

Which Melbourne suburb has the highest crime rate?

A report on Melbourne’s safety indicates that the suburbs with the highest burglary rates include:

  • Mount Dandenong (3767): 8.7 burglary rate.
  • Sorrento (3943): 8.2 burglary rate.
  • East Melbourne (3002): 8.2 burglary rate.
  • St Kilda, St Kilda West (3182): 7.5 burglary rate.
  • Toorak (3142): 7.3 burglary rate.

These suburbs are noted for their higher-than-average burglary rates in Greater Melbourne.

What suburb in Victoria has the most crime?

Regarding serious assaults, a crime report highlights that:

  • Dandenong is the most dangerous suburb for serious assaults outside of Melbourne’s CBD.
  • St Kilda, despite its high real estate prices, records a high number of serious assaults, making it one of the state’s most violent suburbs.
Soho is your expert team in Australian real estate, offering an innovative platform for effortless property searches. With deep insights into buying, renting, and market trends, we guide you to make informed decisions, whether it's your first home or exploring new suburbs.
Share this article
Don’t waste time searching for a home. Let our AI do the work


Soho logo

Our AI match engine will match you with over 150,000+ properties and you can swipe away or shortlist easily. Making your home buying journey faster and easier 

Soho logo
Our AI match engine will match you with over 150,000+ properties and you can swipe away or shortlist easily. Making your home buying journey faster and easier.