Renovate or Rebuild: Your Questions Answered

October 19, 2023

Key takeaways:

  • Renovating allows homeowners to progressively enhance sustainability and preserve the historical and emotional essence of a home.
  • Rebuilding offers a blank canvas to integrate advanced sustainable technologies from the outset and craft a new narrative for the living space.
  • The decision between renovating and rebuilding hinges on various factors, including budget, sustainability goals, emotional attachment, and the current condition of the property.
  • Older homes with character and heritage value might be better off renovated, but new homes generally offer better energy efficiency, easier maintenance, and come with construction warranties.

To renovate or rebuild? That is the question. Of course, both sides will have their advantages and disadvantages. Renovating is cheaper, but if the home is older, it might be more worthwhile to rebuild. Rebuilding is pricier but if you’re in a sought-after area, a new house means even more value.

But don’t worry, we will get into all the essential considerations, from financial implications and regulatory adherence to environmental impact and lifestyle disruptions.

Renovate vs. Rebuild: The Main Differences

Renovate: A Facelift or More?

“The allure of renovation often lies in its perceived cost-effectiveness and the ability to preserve the existing character of the home.”

Renovating may seem like the quickest, most cost-effective solution. However, it’s vital to assess the current state of the property to ensure that renovation is a viable long-term solution.

Particularly in the kitchen, one of the most frequently used spaces in a home, understanding the scope and how much to renovate a kitchen is imperative to set a realistic budget and plan..

Rebuild: A Fresh Start

On the flip side, rebuilding entails demolishing the current structure and constructing a new home on the existing land. This option provides a blank canvas, allowing you to customise your living space, adhere to modern building standards, and potentially enhance energy efficiency.

While seemingly daunting and often perceived as costlier, rebuilding can offer unparalleled customisation and the ability to rectify any existing structural issues definitively.

Questions to ask yourself when wondering whether to renovate or rebuild

  1. Cost Analysis: Is it cheaper to renovate or rebuild considering the changes you want to make?
  2. Age and Heritage: How old is your home? Does it have any heritage or character features that are worth preserving?
  3. Market Conditions: Are you in a location where vacant land is scarce? Would rebuilding add more value to your home than renovating in the current market conditions?
  4. Block Considerations: Is your block flat or sloping? Are there any local planning laws or heritage overlays that might affect your decision?
  5. Logistics and Lifestyle: Are you prepared for the disruption of living in a renovation? Would you prefer the simplicity of a ‘turn key’ new home?
  6. Maintenance and Efficiency: Would a new home be easier and cheaper to maintain? Would it be more energy-efficient?
  7. Customization: Do you want to customize every aspect of your home, or are you okay with working within the constraints of an existing structure?
  8. Sustainability: Are you looking to incorporate modern, low-impact building practices or sustainable features in your home?
  9. Waste Consideration: Are you concerned about the environmental impact and the amount of waste that might end up in landfills due to a rebuild?
  10. Timeline: Would a renovation allow you to move back into your home sooner than a rebuild?

Cost Differences Between Renovating and Rebuilding

Costs of Renovating

Renovating might seem like the financially prudent option at a glance, especially for minor upgrades. However, extensive renovations can quickly escalate in cost, particularly when unforeseen issues like structural or wiring problems arise mid-project.

It’s imperative to:

  • Conduct a thorough inspection of your home
  • Establish a robust budget
  • Factor in a contingency for unexpected costs to navigate through the financial landscape of renovating

Part of this planning might involve figuring out how to renovate for profit, ensuring that the funds invested in the project will enhance the property’s overall value.

Budgeting for a Rebuild

Conversely, rebuilding comes with its own set of financial considerations. While the upfront cost might be higher, it provides a clear slate, potentially eliminating unforeseen expenses related to hidden issues that renovations might unearth.

“Moreover, new builds might qualify for certain grants or incentives, providing additional financial relief.

It’s crucial to obtain accurate quotes, understand all associated costs, and establish a comprehensive budget that encompasses all facets of the rebuilding process.

Ensure to consult with professionals and conduct thorough research to validate all information and navigate through your renovation or rebuilding journey effectively.

Home Improvement Regulations and Permits

Renovating Regulations

If you are going to change the structural elements or external appearance of your home, you will need to adhere to specific regulations and potentially obtain permits.

It’s crucial to explore local council regulations, heritage overlays, and any restrictions that might impact your renovation plans.

Ensuring that your renovations comply with Australian standards and building codes is paramount to avoid legal pitfalls and ensure the safety and longevity of the upgrades.

One example of a state that requires renovation permits is New South Wales (NSW). If you’re planning to do significant renovations in NSW, you’ll often need to obtain a development consent or a construction certificate from your local council.

This ensures that the renovation complies with local planning and building regulations. Always check with your local council before starting any renovation work to determine the specific requirements for your area.

Rebuilding: Permitting and Zoning Laws

From demolition permits to adherence to zoning laws and building codes, each step of the rebuild must be meticulously planned and executed within the legal framework.

Engaging with a knowledgeable builder or a project manager who is well-versed in local regulations can streamline the process, ensuring that your new build adheres to all legal and zoning requirements, providing a hassle-free building journey.

Check out our article on permits and regulations when renovating or rebuilding for more info!

Environmental Considerations and Sustainability

Renovations: Eco-friendly Upgrades?

Renovations provide an opportunity to integrate sustainable features into your existing home. From installing energy-efficient appliances and fixtures to opting for sustainable materials, your renovation can be tailored to minimise environmental impact.

However, the extent to which you can implement sustainable features might be limited by the existing structure and layout of your home, potentially hindering the achievement of optimal energy efficiency.

Rebuilding: Designing with Sustainability in Mind

Opting to rebuild provides a unique opportunity to incorporate sustainability from the ground up. From the orientation of your home to maximise natural light, to integrating advanced insulation and energy-efficient systems, rebuilding allows you to embed sustainability into every facet of the design.

Moreover, new builds enable the incorporation of modern, eco-friendly materials and technologies, potentially offering superior energy efficiency and a reduced environmental footprint compared to renovations.

Quick Fixes vs. Lengthy Builds

Renovations: Swift and Specific

Renovations can often be executed in a relatively short timeframe, especially if they are cosmetic or non-structural.

Simple updates like repainting, new flooring, or updating fixtures can be accomplished quickly, sometimes within a week, providing an almost instant refresh to your living space.

However, extensive renovations that involve structural changes or expansions may take considerably longer, and living on-site during this process can be disruptive.

If you’re living off-site, you will have to consider the costs of doing so.

Rebuilding: A Lengthier Commitment

Rebuilding is undeniably a more time-intensive option. From demolition to construction, the process can span several months or even years, depending on the complexity of the project.

While the end result is a brand-new home tailored to your preferences, the journey involves a significant time commitment and potentially finding alternative accommodation during the build, which can be inconvenient and costly.

Emotional Attachment and Historical Value

Renovating: Honouring the Past

For those with a deep emotional connection to their home or a property with historical significance, renovating allows the preservation of its essence and memories.

Careful and respectful renovations can modernise a space while maintaining its original character and charm, ensuring that the home’s history continues to be celebrated and remembered.

Rebuilding: Crafting a New Narrative

Choosing to rebuild offers a fresh start, enabling you to craft a new narrative for your living space.

While this means letting go of the existing structure and its history, it provides a unique opportunity to create a home that reflects your current lifestyle, preferences, and future aspirations, ensuring that the space is wholly attuned to your needs and desires.

Suggested reading: Don’t stop here! Get a comprehensive breakdown on the cost of renovating a house in our exclusive guide.

FAQ section for renovate or rebuild:

What is the difference between rebuild and renovate?

  • Rebuild: To rebuild a house is to demolish the existing structure and construct a new one from scratch. This is typically done when the existing house is in poor condition or no longer meets the needs of the homeowner.
  • Renovate: To renovate a house is to make improvements to the existing structure without demolishing it. This can include minor updates, such as painting the walls and installing new fixtures, or more significant changes, such as moving walls or adding new rooms.

How much does it cost to rebuild a house in Australia?

The cost to rebuild a house in Australia varies depending on the size and style of the house, the materials used, and the location. However, as a general guide, you can expect to pay between $2,000 and $3,000 per square meter to rebuild a house in Australia.

How much do renovations cost Australia?

As a general guide, you can expect to pay between $10,000 and $20,000 for a minor renovation, such as painting the walls and installing new fixtures. For a more significant renovation, such as moving walls or adding new rooms, you can expect to pay more.

How much does renovation cost per square metre in Australia?

As a general guide, you can expect to pay between $500 and $1,000 per square meter for a renovation.

How much does it cost to renovate a full house Australia?

You can expect to pay between $50,000 and $200,000 to renovate a full house in Australia.

It is important to note that these are just estimates. The actual cost of rebuilding or renovating your home will vary depending on the specific factors mentioned above. It is always best to get quotes from multiple builders or contractors before making a decision.

Here are some tips for budgeting for a rebuild or renovation:

  • Decide on the scope of work. What do you want to change? Once you have a good idea of the scope of work, you can start to estimate the cost of materials and labor.
  • Get quotes from multiple builders or contractors. This will help you to get the best possible price for your project.
  • Factor in a contingency fund. Unexpected expenses can always arise, so it is important to factor in a contingency fund of 10-15% of your budget.
  • Create a budget. Once you have estimated the cost of materials and labor, you can start to create a budget. Be sure to include the cost of permits, inspections, and other fees.

By following these tips, you can create a budget for your rebuild or renovation that is both realistic and affordable.

Soho takes the hassle out of finding your next home. Whether renting, buying or investing, set up your match profile and we'll send you live property matches as they come on the market. Download the Soho app and never miss an agent's message, inspection or new listing. Agents list for free.
Share this article
Want the latest real estate news in your inbox?

Set up your match profile for updates on the best property tips and tools


Soho logo

Our AI match engine will match you with over 150,000+ properties and you can swipe away or shortlist easily. Making your home buying journey faster and easier 

Soho logo
Our AI match engine will match you with over 150,000+ properties and you can swipe away or shortlist easily. Making your home buying journey faster and easier.