Rentvesting Vs Buying: Which is Safer?

January 2, 2024

Key takeaways:

  • Rentvesting involves renting the property you live in while owning an investment property elsewhere.
  • Renvesting offers flexibility and investment potential but also comes with the challenges of not having a permanent residence and managing investment risks.
  • Buying a home to live in represents a stable and permanent living environment with long-term investment potential, but requires a significant financial commitment in terms of mortgage and maintenance.
  • Current market dynamics, such as the low rental vacancy rates and recovering house prices, significantly influence both rentvesting and home buying decisions in Australia.

Rentvesting versus buying a home in Australia presents a vital decision for potential homeowners and investors. This article dives straight into defining rentvesting and its comparison with buying a home.

We’ll explore the financial aspects, the impact on lifestyle choices, and how current market trends influence each option.

Covering everything from the low rental vacancy rates to the recovering housing market, we aim to provide a clear, concise overview, enabling you to make an informed decision on whether to rentvest or buy in today’s Australian property market.

Get ready for a clash of titans as we explore:

  • The financial pros and cons of each approach
  • Lifestyle factors that can tip the scales
  • Hidden risks and potential rewards

What is Rentvesting?

Rentvesting is an innovative approach to property investment in Australia. It involves renting a property where you live while owning an investment property elsewhere. This strategy is gaining traction among Australians who wish to enter the property market but also desire the flexibility that comes with renting.

How Rentvesting Works

These are the factors in a typical rentvesting scenario:

  1. Investment Property Ownership: You buy a property in an area with strong rental demand and potential for capital growth.
  2. Rental Income: The rental income from this property helps cover mortgage and other ownership costs.
  3. Living Arrangements: Meanwhile, you rent a property in an area that suits your lifestyle and budget, which may not necessarily be affordable to buy in.

Pros and Cons of Rentvesting

Rentvesting Vs Buying

Advantages of Rentvesting

Rentvesting comes with a set of compelling benefits:

  • Flexibility: You have the freedom to live in areas that suit your lifestyle or career choices without the hefty price tag of buying there.
  • Investment Potential: There’s an opportunity to invest in high-growth areas, potentially leading to significant capital gains.

Disadvantages of Rentvesting

However, rentvesting is not without its challenges:

  • Lack of Permanent Residence: As a renter, you may need to move frequently, depending on lease agreements and changes in the rental market.
  • Investment Risks: Managing an investment property requires understanding the market and dealing with potential risks like vacancy periods and maintenance costs.

Buying a Home to Live In

The Traditional Home Ownership Approach

Owning a home is a long-cherished aspiration in Australia, symbolizing both financial stability and personal achievement. It involves:

  • Purchasing a Property: Selecting a home that meets both your personal and financial criteria.
  • Long-Term Investment: Typically, homeownership is seen as a long-term investment, with the potential for property value appreciation over time.

Emotional and Financial Investment

Homeownership represents:

  • Security: Providing a stable and permanent living environment.
  • Financial Commitment: Involving mortgage repayments, property maintenance, and other associated costs.

Comparing Costs

AspectRentvestingBuying a Home
Initial InvestmentLower upfront costs for renting; investment property may require a substantial down payment.Generally requires a significant down payment and various purchasing fees.
Ongoing ExpensesRenting costs combined with investment property expenses, offset by rental income.Mortgage repayments, property taxes, maintenance, and other homeownership costs.
Financial FlexibilityPotentially higher due to rental income covering some expenses.Limited by the commitment to mortgage repayments and maintenance costs.
Potential for GrowthDependent on the investment property’s location and market conditions.Tied to the property’s value appreciation in the housing market.

Initial and Ongoing Costs

The financial implications of rentvesting versus buying a home are diverse. Rentvestors balance the costs of renting and managing an investment property, while homebuyers face mortgage repayments and maintenance costs. Understanding these dynamics is crucial in making an informed decision.

Market Influences

Recent trends in the Australian property market impact both rentvesting and buying. For instance, the rising rental prices and low vacancy rates​​​​affect rentvestors, while recovering house prices​​and increased property listings​​influence home buyers.

Impact on Lifestyle

Rentvesting Vs Buying

Living Arrangements: Renting vs. Owning

  • Renting: Offers flexibility and mobility, allowing you to live in desired locations without long-term commitments.
  • Owning: Provides stability and a permanent place to call home, fostering a sense of community and belonging.

Mobility vs. Roots

Choosing between rentvesting and buying largely depends on your lifestyle preferences:

Market Trends in Australia

Rental Market Overview

The Australian rental market has been extremely tight as of September 2023, with the national rental vacancy rate plummeting to a historic low of 1.2%. This has led to record-high rents in most capital cities.

However, the impact varies by location, with cities like Melbourne and Adelaide experiencing particularly steep rent increases, reflecting the diverse nature of Australia’s rental market.

Home Buying Market

The housing market has shown resilience and signs of recovery from the 2022 downturn. House prices are approaching new records, suggesting a robust rebound. Notably, capital cities such as Sydney and Adelaide have witnessed significant house price gains, underlining their strong recovery trajectory.

Having said that, 2024 doesn’t look so clear cut. If you’re interested in finding growth areas, Soho’s article on the Hottest Housing Markets in 2024 will help!

Current Market Dynamics

Recent months have seen a substantial increase in property listings in Australia, indicating a market filled with confidence. This uptick in listings, coupled with the Reserve Bank of Australia maintaining the cash rate at 4.10% in September 2023, has had a notable impact on both the rental and home buying markets.

The stable interest rate environment and increased property listings are shaping the dynamics of Australia’s property market.

Home Loan Considerations

Rentvesting Vs Buying

Financing Options for Rentvestors

Rentvestors often choose investment loans, which differ from traditional home loans. Key aspects include:

  • Interest Rates: Typically higher than standard home loans.
  • Loan Features: May offer interest-only payment options to manage cash flow.

Homeowner Loans

For those buying a home to live in, understanding mortgage options is crucial:

  • Fixed vs. Variable Rates: Deciding between stable payments or flexibility.
  • Loan Terms: Longer terms mean lower monthly payments but more interest over time.

First Home Buyer Strategies

Navigating the Market

First-time buyers should:

  • Research Market Trends: Stay informed about current market conditions.
  • Assess Affordability: Consider both the purchase price and ongoing costs.

Government Incentives

Incentives like the First Home Owner Grant can provide crucial support:

  • Financial Boost: These incentives can reduce the initial financial burden.
  • Eligibility Criteria: It’s important to understand the qualifying conditions.

Long-Term Investment Outlook

Rentvesting as an Investment

Rentvesting offers a unique investment approach. It allows individuals to enter the property market, often in high-growth areas.

“The key is choosing the right property that promises good rental yield and capital growth. The success of this strategy relies heavily on market conditions and property selection.”

Home Value Appreciation

For traditional homeowners, the long-term benefit often comes in the form of property value appreciation. Historically, real estate in Australia has shown a consistent upward trend in value, making it a solid long-term investment.

Making Your Decision

Personal Considerations

When deciding between rentvesting and buying:

  • Lifestyle Choices: Consider how each option aligns with your current and future lifestyle.
  • Financial Goals: Assess each option against your short-term and long-term financial objectives.

Seeking Professional Advice

It’s often beneficial to consult with financial advisors or real estate professionals. They can provide personalized advice based on your financial situation and the current market trends.

Decision FactorsRentvestingBuying a Home
Lifestyle AlignmentHigh flexibility and mobilityStability and a sense of permanence
Financial ImplicationsPotential for high investment returnsLong-term property value appreciation
Market DependencyHeavily influenced by rental and property marketsInfluenced by overall real estate trends
Professional ConsultationAdvisable for investment strategy optimizationRecommended for mortgage and market advice

This concludes our exploration of rentvesting and buying in Australia. We’ve examined the pros and cons, financial implications, lifestyle impacts, market trends, and strategies for making an informed decision.

Whether you choose rentvesting or buying, it’s essential to carefully consider your personal circumstances and seek professional advice to ensure the best outcome for your property journey.

FAQs on ‘Rentvesting Vs Buying’

1. What are the Risks of Rentvesting?

Answer: Rentvesting carries the risk of potential capital loss. If the value of the investment property decreases, there’s a possibility of having to sell it at a loss.

2. Should I Pay Off My Investment Property Quickly in Australia?

Answer: It’s advisable to pay off your investment property quickly, especially if it’s not generating income. Turning a non-profitable property into a cash-generating asset before retirement is a beneficial strategy.

3. Why Do People Opt for Rentvesting?

Answer: Rentvesting, the practice of buying an investment property while renting elsewhere, is popular among young people. It provides a way to enter the housing market, especially in areas where buying is prohibitively expensive for living purposes.

4. Why is Investing in Property Risky?

Answer: Property investment is risky due to its vulnerability to physical damage. Risks include natural disasters, fires, tenant-caused damages, and threats like robbery or vandalism, all of which can impact profitability.

Soho is your expert team in Australian real estate, offering an innovative platform for effortless property searches. With deep insights into buying, renting, and market trends, we guide you to make informed decisions, whether it's your first home or exploring new suburbs.
Share this article
Don’t waste time searching for a home. Let our AI do the work
Soho logo

Our AI match engine will match you with over 150,000+ properties and you can swipe away or shortlist easily. Making your home buying journey faster and easier 

Soho logo
Our AI match engine will match you with over 150,000+ properties and you can swipe away or shortlist easily. Making your home buying journey faster and easier.